{"schema_version":"2","scorer_version":"0.1.0","scoring_version":"prov-4+qual-2+sec-2","generated_at":"2026-11-13T23:30:39.837064Z","repo":{"ref":{"host":"github.com","owner":"fengsp","name":"pencil"},"default_branch":"master","clone_url":"https://github.com/fengsp/pencil.git","html_url":"https://github.com/fengsp/pencil","description":"A web application microframework for Rust","stars":872,"forks":37,"is_fork":false,"is_archived":false,"is_private":false,"size_kb":6173,"primary_language":"Rust","license_spdx":"NOASSERTION","created_at":"2014-11-03T09:37:48Z","pushed_at":"2017-04-30T10:42:49Z","security_policy_url":null,"distribution":{"owner_created_at":"2012-12-07T03:48:50Z","owner_type":"User","release_assets":[]}},"commit_sha":"05abcffbccacb122e398af572fa7e07277d608a1","profile":{"lines_by_language":{"Rust":3302,"Shell":20},"files_by_category":{"source":21,"config":5,"test":5,"binary":4,"other":3,"docs":2},"source_lines":3126,"test_lines":196},"pillars":{"ai_provenance":{"score":0.0,"confidence":0.65,"coverage":1.0,"label":"none-detected","breakdown":{"attributed_share":0.0,"suspected_share":0.0,"estimated_share":0.0,"ai_artifacts":0.0,"flagged_work_units":0.0,"flagged_releases":0.0},"summary":"No AI attribution or AI-consistent velocity signals detected."},"quality":{"score":70.8,"confidence":0.9,"coverage":1.0,"label":"adequate","breakdown":{"complexity":72.5,"duplication":89.0,"lint":100.0,"testing":61.7,"docs":85.0,"type_safety":null,"process":5.0},"summary":"Code quality is adequate: test-to-source ratio 0.06, CI runs tests; 11% of function code in complex or long functions; 2% duplicated lines. Weakest area: process."},"security":{"score":73.1,"confidence":0.85,"coverage":1.0,"label":"adequate","breakdown":{"secrets":100.0,"sast":100.0,"dependencies":null,"ci_actions":null,"posture":0.0,"scorecard":25.0},"summary":"Security posture is adequate: no high-impact findings. Weakest area: posture."}},"analyzer_results":[{"analyzer":"sec-scorecard","pillar":"security","status":"ok","tool_version":"scorecard v5.6.0","metrics":{"aggregate":2.1,"check:Maintained":0.0,"check:Binary-Artifacts":10.0,"check:Code-Review":1.0,"check:CII-Best-Practices":0.0,"check:Security-Policy":0.0,"check:Fuzzing":0.0,"check:License":9.0,"check:Branch-Protection":0.0,"check:SAST":0.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[{"kind":"scorecard-check","description":"Scorecard Maintained: 0/10 (0 commit(s) and 0 issue activity found in the last 90 days -- score normalized to 0)","ref":"Maintained","url":"https://scorecard.dev/viewer/?uri=github.com/fengsp/pencil","weight":1.0},{"kind":"scorecard-check","description":"Scorecard Binary-Artifacts: 10/10 (no binaries found in the repo)","ref":"Binary-Artifacts","url":"https://scorecard.dev/viewer/?uri=github.com/fengsp/pencil","weight":0.0},{"kind":"scorecard-check","description":"Scorecard Code-Review: 1/10 (Found 3/28 approved changesets -- score normalized to 1)","ref":"Code-Review","url":"https://scorecard.dev/viewer/?uri=github.com/fengsp/pencil","weight":0.9},{"kind":"scorecard-check","description":"Scorecard CII-Best-Practices: 0/10 (no effort to earn an OpenSSF best practices badge detected)","ref":"CII-Best-Practices","url":"https://scorecard.dev/viewer/?uri=github.com/fengsp/pencil","weight":1.0},{"kind":"scorecard-check","description":"Scorecard Security-Policy: 0/10 (security policy file not detected)","ref":"Security-Policy","url":"https://scorecard.dev/viewer/?uri=github.com/fengsp/pencil","weight":1.0},{"kind":"scorecard-check","description":"Scorecard Fuzzing: 0/10 (project is not fuzzed)","ref":"Fuzzing","url":"https://scorecard.dev/viewer/?uri=github.com/fengsp/pencil","weight":1.0},{"kind":"scorecard-check","description":"Scorecard License: 9/10 (license file detected)","ref":"License","url":"https://scorecard.dev/viewer/?uri=github.com/fengsp/pencil","weight":0.1},{"kind":"scorecard-check","description":"Scorecard Branch-Protection: 0/10 (branch protection not enabled on development/release branches)","ref":"Branch-Protection","url":"https://scorecard.dev/viewer/?uri=github.com/fengsp/pencil","weight":1.0},{"kind":"scorecard-check","description":"Scorecard SAST: 0/10 (SAST tool is not run on all commits -- score normalized to 0)","ref":"SAST","url":"https://scorecard.dev/viewer/?uri=github.com/fengsp/pencil","weight":1.0}],"data":{"date":"2026-11-02","commit":"05abcffbccacb122e398af572fa7e07277d608a1","matches_head":true},"error":null},{"analyzer":"sec-registry","pillar":"security","status":"ok","tool_version":null,"metrics":{"declared":10.0,"checked":10.0,"missing":0.0,"recent":0.0,"lookup_errors":0.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{"phantom":false},"error":null},{"analyzer":"ai-attribution","pillar":"ai_provenance","status":"ok","tool_version":"signatures-v1","metrics":{"commits":203.0,"attributed_commits":0.0,"attributed_commit_share":0.0,"effective_loc":6245.0,"attributed_loc":0.0,"attributed_loc_share":0.0,"tools_detected":0.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{"attributed_loc_by_commit":{},"tools":{},"monthly":{"2014-11":{"loc":1112,"attributed_loc":0},"2014-12":{"loc":1971,"attributed_loc":0},"2015-01":{"loc":345,"attributed_loc":0},"2015-02":{"loc":255,"attributed_loc":0},"2015-12":{"loc":238,"attributed_loc":0},"2016-01":{"loc":297,"attributed_loc":0},"2016-02":{"loc":1074,"attributed_loc":0},"2016-03":{"loc":594,"attributed_loc":0},"2016-04":{"loc":111,"attributed_loc":0},"2016-05":{"loc":25,"attributed_loc":0},"2016-06":{"loc":71,"attributed_loc":0},"2016-09":{"loc":116,"attributed_loc":0},"2016-10":{"loc":36,"attributed_loc":0}}},"error":null},{"analyzer":"ai-artifacts","pillar":"ai_provenance","status":"ok","tool_version":"signatures-v1","metrics":{"artifacts":0.0,"workflow_agents":0.0,"tools_configured":0.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{"artifacts":[],"workflows":[],"tools":[]},"error":null},{"analyzer":"ai-velocity","pillar":"ai_provenance","status":"ok","tool_version":"prov-4","metrics":{"work_units":131.0,"flagged_units":0.0,"pre_ai_era_bursts":0.0,"pre_ai_era_measured_loc":6245.0,"pre_ai_era_burst_loc":0.0,"measured_loc":6245.0,"flagged_loc":0.0,"flagged_loc_share":0.0,"max_loc_per_hour":59.5,"median_loc_per_hour":32.75,"pr_timed_units":1.0,"excluded_import_loc":0.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{"flagged_loc_by_commit":{},"excluded_import_commits":[]},"error":null},{"analyzer":"ai-release-velocity","pillar":"ai_provenance","status":"ok","tool_version":"prov-4","metrics":{"releases":6.0,"flagged_releases":0.0,"max_loc_per_day":7.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{"releases":[{"from":"0.1.0","to":"0.1.1","loc":0,"days":8.4,"loc_per_day":0.0,"flagged":false},{"from":"0.1.1","to":"0.1.2","loc":0,"days":1.0,"loc_per_day":0.0,"flagged":false},{"from":"0.1.2","to":"0.1.3","loc":127,"days":18.04,"loc_per_day":7.0,"flagged":false},{"from":"0.1.3","to":"0.2.0","loc":25,"days":38.08,"loc_per_day":0.7,"flagged":false},{"from":"0.2.0","to":"0.2.1","loc":0,"days":34.08,"loc_per_day":0.0,"flagged":false},{"from":"0.2.1","to":"0.3.0","loc":223,"days":114.92,"loc_per_day":1.9,"flagged":false}]},"error":null},{"analyzer":"ai-stylometry","pillar":"ai_provenance","status":"ok","tool_version":null,"metrics":{"lines_scanned":3126.0,"index":0.0,"count:narrated_steps":0.0,"per_kloc:narrated_steps":0.0,"files:narrated_steps":0.0,"count:placeholder":0.0,"per_kloc:placeholder":0.0,"files:placeholder":0.0,"count:emoji_in_code":0.0,"per_kloc:emoji_in_code":0.0,"files:emoji_in_code":0.0,"count:assistant_voice":0.0,"per_kloc:assistant_voice":0.0,"files:assistant_voice":0.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{},"error":null},{"analyzer":"sec-secrets","pillar":"security","status":"ok","tool_version":"gitleaks 8.30.1","metrics":{"secrets_current":0.0,"secrets_history":0.0,"secrets_nonprod":0.0,"secrets_low_confidence":0.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{},"error":null},{"analyzer":"sec-sast","pillar":"security","status":"ok","tool_version":"opengrep 1.33.1; rules f1d2b562b414","metrics":{"findings":0.0,"findings_high":0.0,"findings_medium":0.0,"findings_low":0.0,"weighted_findings":0.0,"scanned_lines":3126.0,"parse_errors":1.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{"rulesets":["rust","bash"]},"error":null},{"analyzer":"sec-deps","pillar":"security","status":"skipped","tool_version":null,"metrics":{},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{},"error":null},{"analyzer":"sec-actions","pillar":"security","status":"skipped","tool_version":null,"metrics":{},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{},"error":null},{"analyzer":"sec-posture","pillar":"security","status":"ok","tool_version":null,"metrics":{"check:security_policy":0.0,"check:dependency_updates":0.0,"check:signed_commits":0.0,"check:lockfiles":0.0,"signed_commit_share":0.0,"unpinned_manifests":1.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[{"kind":"posture","description":"Cargo.toml has no lockfile alongside it (unpinned dependencies)","ref":"Cargo.toml","url":null,"weight":0.3}],"data":{},"error":null},{"analyzer":"sec-distribution","pillar":"security","status":"ok","tool_version":null,"metrics":{"signals":0.0,"binary_assets":0.0,"suspicious":0.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{"signals":[],"suspicious":false,"unusual_traction":false,"metadata":true},"error":null},{"analyzer":"qual-complexity","pillar":"quality","status":"ok","tool_version":"lizard 1.25.1","metrics":{"functions":208.0,"function_nloc":1626.0,"mean_ccn":2.41,"p90_ccn":4.0,"complex_functions":4.0,"long_functions":0.0,"many_param_functions":0.0,"risky_nloc_share":0.107},"findings":[],"evidence":[{"kind":"complex-function","description":"get_status_from_code in src/httputils.rs: complexity 59, 63 lines","ref":"src/httputils.rs","url":"https://github.com/fengsp/pencil/blob/05abcffbccacb122e398af572fa7e07277d608a1/src/httputils.rs#L36","weight":0.9833333333333333},{"kind":"complex-function","description":"code in src/http_errors.rs: complexity 25, 29 lines","ref":"src/http_errors.rs","url":"https://github.com/fengsp/pencil/blob/05abcffbccacb122e398af572fa7e07277d608a1/src/http_errors.rs#L128","weight":0.4166666666666667},{"kind":"complex-function","description":"get_description in src/http_errors.rs: complexity 25, 53 lines","ref":"src/http_errors.rs","url":"https://github.com/fengsp/pencil/blob/05abcffbccacb122e398af572fa7e07277d608a1/src/http_errors.rs#L167","weight":0.4166666666666667},{"kind":"complex-function","description":"new in src/http_errors.rs: complexity 25, 29 lines","ref":"src/http_errors.rs","url":"https://github.com/fengsp/pencil/blob/05abcffbccacb122e398af572fa7e07277d608a1/src/http_errors.rs#L96","weight":0.4166666666666667}],"data":{},"error":null},{"analyzer":"qual-duplication","pillar":"quality","status":"ok","tool_version":"repotrust-dup-w6","metrics":{"compared_lines":2050.0,"duplicated_lines":40.0,"duplicated_share":0.0195,"files":21.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[{"kind":"duplicate-code","description":"6+ duplicated lines: src/http_errors.rs:18 and src/http_errors.rs:72","ref":"src/http_errors.rs","url":"https://github.com/fengsp/pencil/blob/05abcffbccacb122e398af572fa7e07277d608a1/src/http_errors.rs#L18","weight":0.3}],"data":{},"error":null},{"analyzer":"qual-lint","pillar":"quality","status":"ok","tool_version":"opengrep 1.33.1; rules f1d2b562b414","metrics":{"findings":0.0,"weighted_findings":0.0,"scanned_lines":3126.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{},"error":null},{"analyzer":"qual-testing","pillar":"quality","status":"ok","tool_version":null,"metrics":{"check:has_tests":1.0,"check:test_ratio":0.1254,"check:ci_present":1.0,"check:ci_runs_tests":1.0,"check:ci_runs_lint":0.0,"check:tests_cochange":0.3529,"test_lines":196.0,"source_lines":3126.0,"test_ratio":0.0627,"ci_files":1.0,"cochange_share":0.0882,"cochange_commits":170.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[{"kind":"ci","description":"CI config: .travis.yml","ref":".travis.yml","url":null,"weight":0.0},{"kind":"ci","description":"CI runs tests (make test)","ref":null,"url":null,"weight":0.0}],"data":{"test_commands":["make test"],"lint_commands":[]},"error":null},{"analyzer":"qual-docs","pillar":"quality","status":"ok","tool_version":null,"metrics":{"check:readme":1.0,"check:license":1.0,"check:contributing":0.0,"check:changelog":1.0,"readme_lines":17.0},"findings":[],"evidence":[{"kind":"docs","description":"README.md","ref":"README.md","url":null,"weight":0.0},{"kind":"docs","description":"LICENSE","ref":"LICENSE","url":null,"weight":0.0},{"kind":"docs","description":"CHANGES","ref":"CHANGES","url":null,"weight":0.0}],"data":{},"error":null},{"analyzer":"qual-type-safety","pillar":"quality","status":"skipped","tool_version":null,"metrics":{},"findings":[],"evidence":[],"data":{},"error":null}],"flags":[]}